So, as I hope you read, I really got torn apart by the good folk over at Ask And Ye Shall Receive.
The review itself wasn’t too bad, overall: Father “Mengele” Gene’s main gripe was that I talk incessantly, not write; although somehow he also thinks I write well, technically. Hmm. No inconsistency there.
Constructive advice? You can clearly write well, technically, but you don’t write, you talk. If you have any interest to improve, re-read what you write and ask yourself do you like what you read. Other than that, stop fucking moaning. You are privileged, go live your life.
Do I like what I read of my own writing? Quite often, the answer is ‘not really’. But I also think that attitude is the height of ridiculousness in art: you can’t shoot a film and then pan it yourself. You can’t think your own paintings, poems, or photographs suck. Of course, thousands of artists do exactly that (and perhaps that’s why we have the stereotype of the tragic artist).
I don’t mean to say that the desire for self-improvement itself is rubbish: for example, on the basketball court I’m constantly critically evaluating myself. I’m always thinking of moves I could have made but didn’t, and why I didn’t make them. (Often the answer is that I’m not athletic or talented enough, and never will be. It doesn’t matter. I love the game anyway.) The same goes for my drumming, driving, and bike riding.
My point is that a certain amount of pride and self-belief is essential for healthy self-esteem. When asked to play something on a musical instrument, or to sing for a group, I believe you should never waste time prefacing your performance with disclaimers: “Oh, I’m not very good,” “Oh, I haven’t practised/played in ages.” You should just sing or play, and let others form their own opinions as to how good you are. Chances are of course that you do suck, but so what? At least you had the guts to perform. If you really believed yourself to be so bad, you wouldn’t have let yourself be talked into performing. You’d have been one of the people in the audience thinking to themselves: “Oh, I wish I could sing/write/act/play/drive/dance like that.” (And I guarantee you, there will be at least one such person.)
So yeah, I think my writing in some/many posts could be “better” (whatever that means), but overall, I kinda like my blog, y’know? If I knew how to do it better, I already would’ve.
The comments page on AAYSR had a lot of people telling me (a) my writing is boring, and (b) I’m a racist for having said that Obama looks like a monkey in that godawful ‘Hope’ picture. (Something I’ve since apologised for.)
Think what you will, but I wasn’t even thinking of Obama as a black man when I called him a monkeyface, and that’s the truth, and all I have to say on the matter anymore.
I tried to reason with the said commenters, but quickly realised that with the exception of one, they weren’t interested in the veracity of their savage attacks on my personality. (Something I didn’t sign up for when I submitted my blog for review; and you’ll notice the review itself never ‘got personal’ at any time.) All that the commenters were/are interested in is their brand of deriving pleasure from assault on other people. They’re not unique, that bunch of commenters: in the many years I spent trawling the internet before and after I set up this blog I’ve seen the phenomenon on forums, in chatrooms, and on other blogs. The regular commenters on the FAIL Blog are an example of what the people at AAYSR could be: profane and slanderous, but also witty, in the extreme. They display an unparalleled mastery of the art of the pun that makes me LOL even. The humourless ass-taking at AAYSRcomments– reminiscent of the mild bullying I was subject to in school– isn’t my brand of condom.
As for being boring, well, whoever you are, and whatever you like to do, I could probably go through my Facebook friends list and find at least ten people who find you boring, your interests boring, your humour boring, your music boring, your writing boring, and your life boring. Chances are you’ll find them boring too. I’m well aware that some people don’t think very much of me or my blog, but as Dumblydorr sternly told Hagrid in Book Four, was it: “Really, Hagrid, if you are holding out for universal popularity, you’ll be holed up for a very long time.” Your time is better spent jacking off than worrying about people who find you and your life boring, trust me.
And yet, why have I felt the need for this little pep talk I’ve just given myself (for that’s really what it is, isn’t it)? In truth, I must admit that the combined force of the review and the comment pasting has adversely affected my inclination to blog. Should I listen to the criticism, and write less and better at the same time?
I’ve thought about it, and I can’t really do the whole “writing for an audience” gig. Trying to make my posts funny, with liberal profanity, over-the-top, incredible hyperbole, and a Ruler-Of-The-Universe point of view, really isn’t my thing. My thing is writing it as I think it. My thing is writing about feeling and being called fat, because I have nowhere else to say it. My thing is being vain and selfglorious here, because I can’t be it elsewhere.
In real life I have far from an overly dominant personality. There’s a tendency to please that (I hope) falls short of doormatdom, but I’ll still put myself out for your convenience, the more so the less intimately I know you. (In short, I try to let strangers have their way.) I’ll even turn off MY Dream Theater in MY car if YOU don’t like it, despite the driver-chooses-the-music rule. Conversely, I never ask anyone to change the music they’re playing. Where I am inflexible is in little things like using coasters, not breaking books’ spines, not touching the laptop screen, not starting in second gear, squeezing toothpaste from the bottom up, and using “correct” grammar and punctuation. (This sort of thing is usually labelled ‘neurotic’, especially by less-inclined family members.)
Saala fucking chootiya maadhar bhehn ki lund, though, this is my weblog and I think I’m going to continue to write it the way I want to. I have my reasons for blogging, and as long as they’re extant, I’m unlikely to stop. Reading is your prerogative, after all; it’s not compulsory military service.
I do hope you’ll stay, though. I have whisky, even though it’s a dry day, and rum can be arranged, if you’d prefer that.